When a slip-and-fall accident occurs due to snow or ice accumulation on a property, the resulting injuries can be serious, leading to significant medical bills and potentially prolonged legal disputes. In these cases, determining who is liable for the accident often requires specialized knowledge about snow and ice removal practices. This is where an expert witness becomes invaluable. An expert witness with a background in snow and ice mitigation can offer insights into whether the proper precautions were taken by property owners or maintenance teams. But what exactly does an expert witness focus on during an investigation?
One of the first things an expert witness will evaluate in a snow and ice accident investigation is whether the property owner or manager followed established industry standards. Snow and ice mitigation involves more than just shoveling snow or spreading salt—it requires a comprehensive approach based on best practices that have been developed and widely accepted within the industry. For example, property owners are expected to monitor weather conditions and respond accordingly to prevent dangerous ice from forming. Failing to meet these standards can be a strong indication of negligence.
Expert witnesses often refer to guidelines issued by organizations such as the Snow and Ice Management Association (SIMA) or standards set by local regulations. They may compare these guidelines to the actual actions taken by the property owner or their snow removal contractor to determine whether reasonable steps were taken to keep the premises safe. This analysis helps provide a clear picture of whether a property owner acted responsibly or if their actions (or inaction) contributed to the accident.
Another critical factor in a snow and ice accident investigation is the weather conditions leading up to the incident. An expert witness will often examine weather reports, forecasts, and historical data to assess whether the property owner had enough warning to address the snow or ice buildup. For example, if a storm was forecasted days in advance, the property owner should have taken steps to arrange for snow removal or ice mitigation efforts. Failing to do so could be seen as a lack of due diligence.
The timeliness of the property owner’s response is also a key focus. Did they wait too long to apply de-icing materials or clear the snow? An expert witness will look at factors such as how long after the snowfall or freezing rain the accident occurred and whether reasonable measures were taken to prevent the buildup of ice. These details help establish whether the property owner or maintenance team acted quickly enough to mitigate hazards and protect visitors or tenants from dangerous conditions.
The physical conditions of the site at the time of the accident are another area that an expert witness will closely examine. They will assess the condition of walkways, parking lots, stairways, and other surfaces where people are likely to walk. Were these surfaces treated appropriately? Was there ice accumulation that could have been prevented with proper attention? These are important questions that help determine whether a property owner fulfilled their duty of care.
In addition to evaluating surface treatments like salt or sand applications, an expert witness will also examine other site-specific factors. For example, poor drainage can lead to water pooling in certain areas, which then freezes and creates hazardous icy patches. If the site’s design or maintenance routines contributed to the buildup of ice, the property owner could be held liable. Grading issues, where the ground is not properly sloped, can cause similar problems. The expert witness will also take into account factors like lighting, surface texture, and visibility. Poor lighting or an uneven walkway can further increase the risk of an accident.
One of the most revealing aspects of a snow and ice accident investigation is the review of maintenance records. Property owners and snow removal companies are typically expected to maintain logs that document their efforts to clear snow and apply de-icing treatments. These logs should include dates, times, and details about the work that was done, such as how much salt was applied or when snow was removed. An expert witness will carefully scrutinize these records to verify whether the property owner or maintenance team performed their duties adequately.
In many cases, a lack of documentation or incomplete records can raise red flags. If a property owner cannot provide clear evidence of their snow and ice mitigation efforts, it may suggest that the necessary precautions were not taken. This lack of documentation can play a significant role in establishing liability. On the other hand, thorough and detailed logs that demonstrate consistent and timely maintenance may help defend the property owner against claims of negligence. An expert witness can identify gaps in these records and offer insights into whether industry standards were met.
Once the expert witness has gathered all relevant information from their investigation—whether it involves reviewing maintenance records, inspecting the site, or analyzing weather conditions—their primary role is to provide clear, fact-based testimony. This testimony can be crucial in both settlement discussions and court proceedings. By explaining the technical aspects of snow and ice removal in simple, understandable terms, the expert helps the court or jury understand whether the property owner or maintenance team took reasonable steps to prevent the accident.
The expert witness may also point out specific areas where negligence occurred, such as failing to treat walkways before the ice formed or ignoring forecasted weather conditions. Their testimony can significantly influence the outcome of the case by offering an authoritative perspective on the standards that should have been followed and whether those standards were met. In many cases, expert testimony can be the deciding factor in establishing whether a property owner is liable for injuries that occurred due to snow and ice hazards.
If you or someone you know has been involved in a snow or ice-related accident, it’s essential to consult with an expert witness to evaluate the case. Contact us today for expert guidance and support in snow and ice accident investigations. Our team has extensive experience in the field and can provide the testimony needed to help establish liability and protect your interests.
Copyright © 2024 ALLIN / ROSE Consulting, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions
